Supreme Court Weighs Condemned Man’s Wish for Pastor’s Touch

WASHINGTON — A Texas inmate’s petition that his pastor beryllium capable to interaction him and commune aloud with him successful the decease enclosure met a mixed reception connected Tuesday astatine the Supreme Court.

Some justices said the petition was a humble 1 that respected the inmate’s close to workout his religion successful his last moments.

“You should person a pastor to assistance usher you to the different place,” Justice Sonia Sotomayor said.

But different members of the tribunal disquieted astir their competence to supervise execution protocols, to justice the sincerity of inmates’ spiritual convictions, to forestall litigation gamesmanship and to grip what Justice Samuel A. Alito Jr. said could go “an unending stream” of lawsuits requesting each sorts of spiritual accommodations.

Chief Justice John G. Roberts Jr. asked astir requests to person much than 1 spiritual advisor successful the execution enclosure and astir last-minute conversions to caller faiths. Justice Brett M. Kavanaugh asked astir a petition for “bread and vino successful the execution room.” Justice Alito disquieted that judges would beryllium required “to spell done the full quality anatomy” to determine wherever touching was permitted.

Seth Kretzer, a lawyer for the inmate, John H. Ramirez, said it was Texas’ protocol that was a moving target, arsenic the authorities had allowed touching and audible supplication by spiritual advisers astatine 572 executions implicit 4 decades done 2019.

Justice Kavanaugh said “that does not determination maine astatine all,” arsenic the chaplains astatine those executions were situation employees and frankincense not a information risk.

Mr. Ramirez was sentenced to decease for the 2004 execution of a convenience store worker. Mr. Ramirez stabbed the worker, Pablo Castro, 29 times successful a robbery that yielded pouch change.

In prison, Mr. Ramirez forged a narration with Dana Moore, the pastor of Second Baptist Church successful Corpus Christi, Tex. Mr. Ramirez asked that his pastor beryllium allowed to interaction him and commune retired large with him arsenic helium dies.

When situation officials rejected his request, citing information concerns, Mr. Ramirez sued, saying the argumentation violated his close to workout his religion astatine the infinitesimal when, arsenic his lawyer enactment it successful a brief, “most Christians judge they volition either ascend to eden oregon descend to hellhole — successful different words, erstwhile spiritual acquisition and signifier is astir needed.”

An execution, Justice Kavanaugh said, is “a precise fraught concern with a batch of imaginable for issues.”

Mr. Kretzer responded that determination was “not a azygous illustration successful history” of a spiritual advisor interfering with an execution.

Justice Elena Kagan asked Judd E. Stone II, Texas’ solicitor general, if helium was “aware successful immoderate different states of an execution going astray due to the fact that of an extracurricular spiritual adviser.” Mr. Stone said no.

Eric J. Feigin, a lawyer for the national authorities who argued successful enactment of neither side, drew distinctions that seemed to entreaty to immoderate of the justices. He said audible prayers from spiritual advisers were communal astatine caller national executions, but touching was uncommon and should not beryllium allowed erstwhile the lethal chemicals were being administered.

Federal situation authorities, helium said, “would person very, precise important concerns astir that due to the fact that of the hazard of either advertent oregon inadvertent disruption of the IV lines.”

“Someone could faint, idiosyncratic could stumble, and you could jostle the lines,” helium said.

Mr. Kretzer said it would suffice to fto Mr. Moore interaction Mr. Ramirez’s foot.

Understand the Supreme Court’s Momentous Term

Justice Alito said different prisoners would person antithetic requests. “What’s going to happen,” helium asked, “when the adjacent captive says that I person a spiritual content that helium should interaction my knee? He should clasp my hand? He should enactment his manus implicit my heart? He should beryllium capable to enactment his manus connected my head?”

Justice Alito noted that the Supreme Court has taken a assortment of approaches to suits successful which decease enactment inmates asked that their spiritual advisers beryllium contiguous to comfortableness them during their past minutes. The caller case, Ramirez v. Collier, No. 21-5592, was, helium said, lone the latest elaboration.

“We person had a full bid of enactment applications that contiguous issues that are related to the 1 that is presented here, and each 1 has been different,” helium told Mr. Kretzer. “And what you person said truthful acold suggests to maine that we tin look guardant to an unending watercourse of variations.”

In 2019, for instance, the tribunal allowed by a 5-to-4 vote the execution of an Alabama inmate, Domineque Ray, a Muslim whose petition that his imam beryllium contiguous had been denied. At the time, Alabama allowed lone a Christian chaplain employed by the situation strategy to connection spiritual guidance to condemned inmates during their past moments.

A fewer weeks later, the tribunal confronted a akin lawsuit from Texas and came to a antithetic conclusion, staying the execution of a Buddhist inmate whose petition that his spiritual advisor beryllium contiguous successful the execution enclosure had been denied.

In a concurring opinion, Justice Kavanaugh wrote that states could exclude advisers of each denominations from the execution chamber, but whitethorn not let lone immoderate to beryllium present.

Alabama responded by excluding each spiritual advisers from the decease chamber. In February, the Supreme Court nevertheless let basal a ruling that halted the execution of an Alabama inmate, Willie B. Smith III, a Christian, unless the authorities allowed his pastor to beryllium contiguous successful the decease chamber.

“Alabama has not carried its load of showing that the exclusion of each clergy members from the execution enclosure is indispensable to guarantee situation security,” Justice Kagan wrote for 4 justices successful a concurring opinion. “So the authorities cannot present execute Smith without his pastor present, to easiness what Smith calls the ‘transition betwixt the worlds of the surviving and the dead.’”